Email to Aunt Saunny      

Recipe Categories: Saunny62's HOME PAGEAMISHBreads AMISHBreakfast AMISHCakes AMISHCandies AMISHDesserts AMISHMainCourses AMISHPies AMISHSalads AMISHSnacks AMISHSoups AMISHVeggies APPETIZERSBalls APPETIZERSwBacon APPETIZERSwCheese APPETIZERSwChicken APPETIZERSwMeat APPETIZERSwMiscellaneous APPETIZERSwSeafoods APPETIZERSwVeggies BARSandSNACKCAKES BEAUTYTIPSDressing BEAUTYTIPSFeet BEAUTYTIPSHair BEAUTYTIPSSkin BEEFFiletMignon BEEFFlank BEEFGround BEEFMiscellaneous BEEFRibye BEEFRound BEEFSirloin BEVERAGESMiscellaneous BEVERAGESwCHOCOLATE BEVERAGESwFRUIT BEVERAGESwithCOFFEEorTEA BEVERAGESwLiquor BEVERAGESwSMOOTHIES BEVERAGESwSodaorSoftDrinks BREADSBagels BREADSBiscuits BREADSBreadMachines BREADSCornbreads BREADSDumplings BREADSMiscellaneous BREADSMuffins BREADSRolls BREADSScones BREADSSpreads BREADSSticks BREADSStuffings BREAKFASTBlintzes BREAKFASTBrunch BREAKFASTCerals BREAKFASTCrepesandMuffins BREAKFASTMainDishes BREAKFASTOmelets BREAKFASTPancakes BREAKFASTPastries BREAKFASTQuiche BREAKFASTSyrups BREAKFASTToasts BREAKFASTVeggies BREAKFASTWaffles BROWNIES CAJUNMainDishes CAJUNMiscellaenous CAJUNVeggies CAKESAngelFood CAKESBundt CAKESCupcakes CAKESfromSCRATCH CAKESFrostingsnGlazes CAKESFruitcakes CAKESMiscellaneous CAKESPound CAKESwithMIXES CANDYFudges CANDYHard CANDYMiscellaneous CANDYNutty CANDYSoftnCreamy CANDYTaffy CANDYToffee CANDYTruffles CANNING CANNINGConserves CANNINGFruits CANNINGJams CANNINGJellies CANNINGMarmalades CANNINGPickles CANNINGRelishes CANNINGTips CANNINGVegetables CASSEROLES CHEESECAKES CHEESEDishes CHICKEN CHILIS CLEANUPTIPS COBBLERS COOKIES COOKIESBalls COOKINGTIPS COPYCATS CRAFTSforFUN CRAFTSMakingSoap CROCKPOTAppetizers CROCKPOTBeef CROCKPOTBreakfast CROCKPOTChicken CROCKPOTDesserts CROCKPOTMiscellaneous CROCKPOTPork CROCKPOTSoups CROCKPOTVeggie DESSERTS DIPSforBreadorCrackers DIPSforChips DIPSforCrackers DIPSforFruits DIPSforPretzels DIPSforSeafoods DIPSforVeggies DIPSnBALLS DIPSwBacon DIPSwCheese FILLINGSCakesnSuch FISHCatfish FISHCod FISHFillets FISHFlounder FISHHalibut FISHSalmon FISHSnapper FISHSole FISHSwordfish FISHTrout FISHTuna FISHWalleye FISHWhite FLAVORINGSandHERBMIXES FREEZINGJamsJellysandetc FREEZINGTips FREEZINGVegetables FROSTINGS GARDENINGTIPS GIFTSnAJAR GRILLING GRILLINGVeggies HEALTHYFOODS HERBMixesNSpices HERBTips HOLIDAYChanukahORHanukkah HOLIDAYChristmas HOLIDAYHalloween HOLIDAYMardiGras HOLIDAYStPatrick HOLIDAYThanksgiving HOLIDAYValentinesDay HOMEREMEDIES HOUSEHOLDTips ICECREAM ICECREAMMaltsnSodasnSundaes ICECREAMPiesnCakes ICECREAMSherbertsnSorberts ICECREAMToppings ICECREAMYogurtsnIcePops ITALIAN JELLOS KIDSCanMakeRecipes KIDSTreats KITCHEN-HUMOR KOSHER MARINADES MEATBatters MEATSMiscellaneous MEXICANAppetizers MEXICANBreads MEXICANBurritos MEXICANChimichangas MEXICANDesserts MEXICANEnchiladas MEXICANFlautas MEXICANMainCourses MEXICANQuesadillas MEXICANSalads MEXICANSalsasandSauces MEXICANSoupStewsChilis MEXICANTacos MEXICANTamales MEXICANVeggies MICROWAVE ORIENTALMainDishes ORIENTALMiscellaneous ORIENTALSideDishes PASTA PASTAAngelHair PASTABowTie PASTAElbow PASTAFettuccine PASTAFusilli PastaLinguini PASTANoodles PASTAPenne PASTARigatoni PASTARotini PASTAShells PASTAVermicelli PASTAZiti PASTRIES PETBiscuitsorCookies PETMainCourse PIESCreamORMeringue PIESCrusts PIESFruit PIESTarts PIZZA POEMSandTHOUGHTS PORKButts PORKChops PORKHam PORKLoins PORKRibs PORKRoasts PORKSausage PORKSteaks POULTRY PUDDINGS PUDDINGSBread PUDDINGSCustard PUDDINGSMousse RICE SALADDressings SALADSFruit SALADSVegetable SALADSwMeats SANDWICHES SANDWICHESWraps SAUCESBarBQue SAUCESChutney SAUCESGravies SAUCESMiscellaneous SAUCESRelishes SAUCESSalsas SHELLFISHClams SHELLFISHCrabs SHELLFISHCrawfish SHELLFISHLobster SHELLFISHMussels SHELLFISHOysters SHELLFISHPrawns SHELLFISHScallops SHELLFISHShrimp SNACKS SOUPSCheese SOUPSChowders SOUPSMiscellaneous SOUPSwMeats SOUPSwVeggies SPREADS STEWS TURKEY VEGGIEArtichokes VEGGIEAsparagus VEGGIEBakeBeans VEGGIEBatters VEGGIEBeanslimaandetc VEGGIEBeets VEGGIEBlackeyedPeas VEGGIEBroccoli VEGGIEBrusselSprouts VEGGIECabbage VEGGIECarrots VEGGIECauliflower VEGGIECorn VEGGIECucumber VEGGIEEggplant VEGGIEGreenBeans VEGGIEGritsandHominy VEGGIELeafyGreens VEGGIEMixed VEGGIEMushroom VEGGIEOkra VEGGIEOnion VEGGIEParsnips VEGGIEPeas VEGGIEPeppers VEGGIEPotatoes VEGGIEPumpkin VEGGIERhubarb VEGGIERutabagas VEGGIESauerkraut VEGGIESquash VEGGIESweetPotatoes VEGGIETomatoes VEGGIETurnips VEGGIEYams WILDGAMEAlligator WILDGAMEBear WILDGAMEBuffalo WILDGAMEDeer WILDGAMEDuck WILDGAMEFrogs WILDGAMEPossum WILDGAMEQuail WILDGAMERabbit WILDGAMERattlesnake WILDGAMESKUNK WILDGAMESquirrel WILDGAMETurkey WILDGAMETurtle

Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies




Source of Recipe


Aunt Saunny

This recipe can be mixed by hand or in an electric mixer. Use smooth peanut butter rather than chunky. I get good results with Skippy.

Yields eighteen 2-1/2-inch sandwiches.

For the cookies:

6 oz. (1-1/3 cups) all-purpose flour
2 oz. (2/3 cup) cake flour
1/2 tsp. baking soda
1/4 tsp. salt
6 oz. (12 Tbs.) unsalted butter, completely softened at room temperature
3/4 cup smooth peanut butter
1/2 cup sugar
1/2 cup firmly packed light brown sugar
1 tsp. pure vanilla extract
1 large egg


For the filling:


1-1/2 cups confectioners' sugar
3 oz. (6 Tbs.) unsalted butter, softened at room temperature
3/4 cup smooth peanut butter
3 Tbs. heavy cream
1/4 cup coarsely chopped roasted unsalted peanuts
1/4 cup coarsely chopped semisweet chocolate, or mini semisweet chocolate chips

Instead of cross-hatching with a fork, use your fingers to press and decorate.

To make the cookies -- Heat the oven to 350°F. Line two baking sheets with parchment. In a medium bowl, sift together the two flours, baking soda, and salt. In the bowl of an electric mixer, cream the butter, peanut butter, and sugars with the paddle attachment until light and fluffy. Add the vanilla and egg; continue creaming until smooth and fluffy, about 3 min. with an electric mixer (longer by hand). Stir in the flour mixture by hand just until it's incorporated; don't overmix or the cookies will be tough. Drop heaping tablespoonfuls of batter, spaced about 2 inches apart, onto the lined baking sheets. With floured fingers, flatten each dab of batter into a 2-inch round. Bake until the cookies are puffed and golden, 12 to 14 min., rotating the baking sheets if needed for even baking. Transfer the cookies to a rack to cool.

An offset spatula is handy for spreading the cookie filling easily and evenly. A blunt table knife works, too.

While the cookies cool, make the filling -- In a small bowl, cream the confectioners' sugar, butter, and peanut butter until smooth. Add the heavy cream; continue creaming until smooth and fluffy. Stir in the chopped peanuts and chocolate.

To assemble -- Transfer the cooled cookies to a work surface, flipping half of them over. With an offset spatula or a butter knife, spread a scant teaspoon of filling onto each turned-over cookie. Set another wafer on top of each filled cookie, pressing gently to spread the filling. Store sealed at room temperature or in the refrigerator.